Infographic: Solyndra v The Solar Industry
Solyndra vs. the Solar Industry
The high-profile bankruptcy of solar manufacturer Solyndra has given naysayers a soapbox to suggest there’s something wrong with the solar industry as a whole. A closer look, however, reveals that the solar industry is booming and Solyndra’s failure was, in many ways, the result of the solar market’s overall success.
When Solyndra began, it was a cost-competitive option in the solar market. Today, however, Solyndra’s reputed cost structure is significantly higher than the average price for solar modules. This steep decline in price resulted in significant losses for Solyndra.
- Revenue in 2010: $142 M
- Net losses in 2010: $329 M
- Average price October 2008: $4.2/watt
- Solyndra: $2/watt
- Average price today: $1.5/watt
- U.S. GDP Growth (2009-2010): 2.8%
- U.S. Solar Market Growth (2009-2010): 67%
- 2009 U.S. Solar Market: $3.6 billion
- 2010 U.S. Solar Market: $6 billion
- 2007: $7.9/watt
- 2008: $7.6/watt
- 2009: $7.5/watt
- 2010: $6.2/watt
- 2011 (Q1): $5.5/watt
When the company filed for bankruptcy in September 2011, it also laid off the majority of its staff. 1,100 positions at Solyndra were eliminated when the company filed for bankruptcy.
The Solar Industry
The U.S. solar industry is creating jobs faster than the U.S. economy as a whole. Between August 2010 and August 2011, the number of solar jobs grew by 6.8 percent. 6,735 new jobs were added. 100,237 workers were employed by U.S. solar businesses as of August 2011.
- Traditional job growth (1998-2007): 3.7%
- Clean economy job growth (1998-2007): 9.1%
- National median wage: $38,616
- Median wage of typical clean economy job: $44,000
In addition to the government loan, Solyndra received more than $1 billion in private funding. At the time of bankruptcy filing, the company declared nearly $784 million in secured debt.
- Private capital funding: $1.1 billion
- DOE guaranteed loan: $535 million
- Assets as of Jan. 1: $859 million
- Debts as of Jan. 1: $749 million
- 82% ($3.6 billion) came from the photovoltaics sector.
- 9% ($419 million) came from the concentrating solar sector.
- 9% ($400 million) came from the solar heating and cooling sector.
On the World Stage
When Solyndra secured the DOE loan, thin-film solar was a cost-competitive alternative to silicon-based panels. However, global market forces ultimately made silicon more competitive. The price of silicon-based panels, made mainly in China and with which Solyndra was competing, fell 46 percent between 2009 and 2011.
The Solar Industry
The U.S. is currently running a $1.9 billion trade surplus in solar technologies. Compare that to a $250 billion trade deficit in petroleum.
- Solar imports: $3,750 million
- Solar exports: $5,630 million
- Net solar exports: $1,880 million
Putting it in perspective: The Solyndra Loan
The financial losses from Solyndra were extensive. However, the loan guarantee was only 1.3 percent of the funds the government set aside for clean-energy projects
- Solyndra loan: $535 million
- Clean energy loan guarantee program: $38.6 billion
- BrightSource Energy: $1.6 billion
- Abengoa Solar: $1.4 billion
- Caithness Shepherds Flat: $1.3 billion
- Abengoa Solar (Mojave Solar): $1.2 billion
- Agua Caliente: $967 million
- NextEra Energy Resources: $852 million
- Solyndra: $535 million
- Abound Solar: $400 million
- LS Power Associates: $343 million
- Solo Power: $197 million
Another Government-Backed Flop
But Solyndra isn’t alone when it comes to government-subsidized companies that have failed. Consider Enron, which filed for bankruptcy in September 2001.
- Solyndra: $535 million loan
- Enron: $1.2 billion loan
- May 2005: Solyndra is founded to provide a competitive alternative to silicon-based panels as a silicon shortage drives prives of solar photovoltaics.
- Jul 2005: The Bush Administration signs the Energy Policy Act of 2005, which creates the 1703 loan guarantee program.
- Feb-Oct 2006: Solyndra raises first-round funding from CMEA Capital, Argonaut Venture Capital, Madrone Capital Partners, and others, which were part of a $78.2 million fund.
- Dec 2006: Solyndra applies for a loan guarantee as part of the Department of Energy loan program.
- Late 2007: Solyndra is approved as one of 16 clean-tech companies to move forward in the loan guarantee program under the Bush Administration’s DOE.
- Nov 2008: With silicon prices still high, the company is an attractive investment and raises more funding, bringing total private investment to more than $450 million.
- Jan 2009: Shortly before President Obama is inaugurated, the Bush Administration tries to bring Solyndra before a DOE credit review committee, which remands the loan back to DOE because it wasn’t ready for conditional commitment.
- March 2009: The credit committee approves the loan application. Staff at the DOE issue a conditional commitment setting out the terms.
- Jun 2009: Silicon prices begin to drop as more silicon production facilities grow. Between June 2009 and August 2011, photovoltaics prices fall by more than 50 percent.
- Sep 2009: The company raises $219 million more shortly before the DOE secures the $535 million loan guarantee. The close on the loan guarantee occurs roughly three years after the application is submitted.
- Jan-Jun 2010: The price of silicon-based PV continues its steady fall. Investors question Solyndra’s ability to compete at the same time the company raises $175 million more.
- Feb 2011: Rather than liquidate the company, the DOE decides to give Solyndra a chance. Investors pump in $75 million to restructure the loan guarantee.
- Jun 2011: The average price for solar modules falls to $1.50 per watt. Analysts worry about how the company will compete, even though Solyndra says it has cut costs.
- Aug 2011: The DOE refuses to restructure the loan guarantee for a second time.
- Sep 2011: Solyndra files for bankruptcy, lays off workers, and shutters its manufacturing facility.
What’s One Block Off the Grid?
One Block Off the Grid organizes group deals on solar energy. Since 2008, One Block Off the Grid has run hundreds of group deals in over 40 U.S. states and helped thousands of homeowners go solar. We’ve been featured in dozens of publications and programs including The New York Times, The Economist, The Wall Street Journal, Huffington Post, USA Today, Marketplace, Wired, and GOOD Magazine. In 2010, One Block Off the Grid sponsored the first-ever solar deal on Groupon.com and received a Heart of Green Award for “Best New Innovation.” Want to find out if there’s a group deal on solar in your area? Sign up for One Block Off the Grid (it’s free). Not ready to go solar, but want to help take solar mainstream? Tell your friends about One Block Off the Grid.